The Self as Hypothesis

Constructing Identity Through Experimentation Rather Than Goals

Bishal's Instagram

We live in a culture that worships clarity.

Teenagers are asked to choose careers they don’t understand. Professionals are told to map out five-year plans in industries that might not exist in five years. Every January, people are asked to predict who they will be in December—as if identity is a spreadsheet and the world is a stable background.

But here is the quiet, uncomfortable truth underneath all of this:

You are making plans with a mind that does not yet know itself, in a world that does not yet exist.

That doesn’t mean planning is useless. It means something more subtle, and more liberating: humans are insight-limited—so rigid goals are illusions.

The game is not “perfectly predict your future and then march toward it without flinching.” The game is “live in such a way that, as your insight grows, your life can easily be re-aligned with what you now see.”

In a world obsessed with precise destinations, this is a radical shift: From worshiping rigid goals → to respecting the moving frontier of your own understanding.

The Counterintuitive Truth About Goals

Most people think the clearer and more specific the goal, the safer the future.

But the reality is the clearer and more rigid the goals, the more fragile the human behind it becomes.

Rigid goals feel safe because they reduce uncertainty on paper. They give you a sentence you can recite: “I will become X by Y date.”

But that sentence hides three dangerous assumptions:

1. That you already understand what X really is.

2. That X will still matter to you when you get there.

3. That the path to X won’t reveal something better—or something misaligned.

When those assumptions are wrong, the very structure that was meant to guide you becomes a trap. You don’t just fail to hit the goal; you shape years of your life around illusions.

This is why so many people “succeed” and still feel like they’ve lost. They reached a destination that no longer matches the person who arrived there.

Human Nature in an Unknowable World

To understand why this keeps happening, we have to zoom out beyond productivity hacks and planners and look at human nature.

Humans are story-driven, not spreadsheet-driven. We don’t just want outcomes; we want a story in which those outcomes make sense.

We are born into cultures that hand us scripts:

• “This is success.”

• “This is a respectable path.”

• “These are the milestones you should chase.”

  
  

Those scripts make life feel simpler, but they come with a cost: they smuggle in other people’s values as if they were our own.

Psychologically, we crave control and belonging. Rigid goals promise both:

• Control: “I know exactly what I’m aiming at.”

• Belonging: “My goals match what society approves of.”

  
  

But both can be counterfeit. Control is fake if it ignores how little we actually know. Belonging is hollow if it’s built on a life that doesn’t fit us.

Meanwhile, our identity is not static. The 16-year-old “you” choosing a career and the 30-year-old “you” living it are, in many ways, different people with different clarity, preferences, and thresholds for meaning.

Machines do well when the goal is fixed. Give an algorithm a clear objective function, and it will optimize it ruthlessly.

Humans are different. We discover our objective function as we move.

This is the fundamental contrast:

• Machines: tuned for utility and optimization.

• Humans: wired for meaning, narrative, and evolving values.

• Machines act on fully specified instructions.

• Humans act to discover who they are and what matters as they go.

• Doers execute tasks.

• Directors step back, ask why the task exists, who it serves, and whether the story is still worth living.

  
  

If you treat yourself like a machine—fixed goal, fixed identity, fixed path—you will get machine-like outcomes: efficient, impressive, and often emotionally empty.

The art is to be a builder who respects both realities:

• The need to act.

• And the fact that your understanding, values, and identity are still under construction.

The Core Shift Happening in the World

We are living through a three-layer transformation that makes rigid goals more fragile than ever.

1. Power transferred from institutions → individuals

For most of history, institutions set your goals for you: religion, family, state, guild, company. You didn’t decide what success meant; you inherited it.

Now, power is drifting:

• Careers are more fluid.

• Geography is less binding.

• Digital leverage lets one person do what once required an organization.

  
  

Power transferred from “follow the script” → “author the script.”

That sounds inspiring, but it means: if you don’t learn to design your own intentions, you become a slave to algorithms, trends, and other people’s plans.

2. Phase 1, 2, 3: How we think about goals

• Phase 1: Survival Goals “I just need to get by.” Food, safety, basic stability. The goal is obvious: stay alive, stay afloat.

• Phase 2: Achievement Goals (the age of SMART goals)“I must optimize.” Promotions, degrees, specific targets. Success is defined by clear metrics.

• Phase 3: Intention Alignment “I want my actions, identity, and values to line up—even as they evolve.” Here, goals become tools, not gods. They are hypotheses to be tested, not prophecies to be obeyed.

  
  

We are collectively transitioning from Phase 2 to Phase 3.Those who cling to Phase 2 thinking in a Phase 3 world are the ones who feel the most lost: hyper-optimized and deeply misaligned.

3. This era shifts the value from prediction → adaptability

We used to believe the person who could predict the future would win. Now, the person who can absorb reality, update, and realign quickly wins.

This era shifts the value from “I know where I’ll be in 10 years” → “I know how to stay honest with myself as I change.”

Three Human Superpowers in an Insight-Limited World

If rigid goals are illusions, what replaces them?

Not laziness. Not drifting.

We replace fragile prediction with three human superpowers that machines cannot fully copy.

1. Reflective Awareness

This is your ability to watch your own mind: To notice, “I wanted this five years ago. Do I still want it? Or do I just feel guilty changing my mind?”

Reflective awareness turns your life into feedback, not fate.

Practically, it looks like:

• Journaling after major decisions.

• Asking, “What did this actually feel like?” instead of “Did this match the plan?”

• Seeing anxiety or boredom as data, not personal failures.

  
  

In a world of rigid goals, self-reflection is avoided because it might ask you to course-correct. In a world of intention alignment, self-reflection is the steering wheel.

Every time you practice reflective awareness, you reclaim a bit more of your life from autopilot. You move from being carried by your goals → to consciously choosing your direction.

2. Intentional Experimentation

Instead of saying, “This is my path forever,” you say, “This is my next experiment.”

You treat careers, habits, projects, even identities as trials:

• “For six months, I’ll live as if I’m the kind of person who prioritizes creativity.”

• “For this year, I’ll test what happens if I take my health seriously.”

  
  

You don’t need perfect insight upfront because your experiments are designed to teach you. Success becomes: “Did I learn something real about myself and the world?” — not just “Did it look good on a resume?”

This turns motion into a self-correcting loop instead of a one-shot gamble. By experimenting on purpose, you trade the illusion of certainty for the reality of progress.

3. Constructed Values

We often talk about “finding your values” as if they’re buried treasure. But in practice, your values are constructed through experience, reflection, and choice.

You learn that:

• Freedom matters to you when you taste both constraint and autonomy.

• Impact matters when you see the difference between shallow praise and meaningful contribution.

• Integrity matters when you notice how it feels to hide vs. to be honest.

  
  

Instead of waiting to “discover” your values in a single epiphany, you:

1. Live.

2. Reflect.

3. Abstract lessons about what mattered.

4. Use those lessons to refine what you stand for.

   
   

The more consciously you construct your values, the less likely you are to live by borrowed ones. You move from being shaped by other people’s scripts → to shaping the script you are willing to live and die by.

The world rewards the adaptable, self-aware builder more than the rigid long-term forecaster.

Two Kinds of People Emerging: Goal-Chasers vs Intention-Builders

Let’s draw a hard line, because this is where the path splits.

You can live as a Goal-Chaser or an Intention-Builder.

Goal-Chasers

Goal-Chasers measure their life in boxes ticked.

They feel safe when their calendar is full and their roadmap is fixed.

They outsource their sense of meaning to outcomes:

• “Once I become X, I’ll feel worthy.”

• “Once I earn Y, I’ll feel secure.”

  
  

When reality shifts, they don’t update; they double down. They fear changing their goal more than they fear wasting their life.

Goal-Chasers are efficient, but brittle. If the goal cracks, so do they.

Intention-Builders

Intention-Builders still set goals. They just refuse to worship them.

Their primary question is not “What do I want to achieve?” but “What kind of person am I trying to become—and is my current way of living aligned with that?”

They see every plan as a draft. Every season as an experiment. Every achievement as feedback about what does or doesn’t actually fulfill them.

They are willing to do something most people find terrifying: update their identity when new insight arrives.

Where Goal-Chasers seek certainty, Intention-Builders seek alignment. Where Goal-Chasers cling to a single path, Intention-Builders learn to redesign the path without losing themselves.

This is not about who works harder. It’s about who takes responsibility for directing their life while admitting, “I don’t fully know myself yet—but I’m committed to learning.”

Practical Pathways: From Illusion to Intentional Living

Philosophy is useless if it stays in the clouds.

Here are concrete pathways to live as an Intention-Builder in an insight-limited world.

1) Become a Student of Your Own Life

Why it matters now: In a fast-changing world, your main durable edge is how quickly you can learn from your own experience.

Mental model: Treat your life like a continuous experiment. Every day generates data: what energized you, what drained you, where you felt proud, where you felt fake.

Practice:

At the end of the day, write down three things:

1. What felt aligned?

2. What felt off?

3. What did this reveal about what you might truly value?

Don’t judge. Observe.

Benefit: Instead of waiting for a quarter-life or midlife crisis to re-evaluate your direction, you’re updating continuously.

You are no longer just living → you are learning yourself while you live.

2) Train the “Hypothesis, Not Destiny” Mindset

Why it matters now: Jobs, markets, technologies, and identities are shifting too quickly for any single decision to be final. You need a way to commit without pretending it’s forever.

Mental model: Every big decision is a hypothesis:

“Given what I know now, this seems like the next best move.”

Set a time horizon: 3 months, 6 months, 1 year.

Commit fully for that period, not for eternity.

Practice: Before starting a job, project, or path, write:

• What am I hoping this gives me (skills, experiences, feelings)?

• How will I know it’s not working?

• When will I review this decision?

  
  

Put that review date in your calendar. When it comes, evaluate honestly.

Benefit:

You can go all-in without being trapped. Your courage to start increases because you’re no longer secretly promising your future self that this must be “the one.”

You shift from “I must get this right forever” → to “I must be honest enough to update when new insight arrives.”

3) Develop a Portfolio of Micro-Experiments

Why it matters now: You cannot think your way into knowing who you are. At some point, you have to collect evidence.

Mental model: Instead of one massive “life goal,” run many small experiments that probe different versions of you.

Example micro-experiments:

• Teach something you know to a small group for four weeks.

• Spend 30 days waking up 1 hour earlier to work on a personal project.

• Volunteer in a space you’re curious about.

• Shadow someone in a field you think you want to pursue.

  
  

Each experiment answers a simple question: “Does this feel like part of a life I’d be proud to expand?”

Benefit:

You reduce the risk of building your entire identity on fantasies. You make future decisions with evidence, not just imagination.

This is how you move from living on borrowed dreams → to constructing your own.

4) Build a Reflection Ritual Around Identity

Why it matters now: Your goals keep changing because you keep changing, but most people never consciously track that evolution.

Mental model:

Once a month, schedule a 60–90 minute “identity review.” Ask:

• Who did I try to be this month?

• Where did my actions align with that identity?

• Where did they contradict it?

• What did I learn about the kind of person I do not want to become?

  
  

This is not about shame. It’s about updating the blueprint.

Benefit: You stop obsessing over “What did I achieve?” and start asking “Who am I turning into?”

You become less afraid of changing your goals because you’ve built a stable anchor:

your evolving but honest sense of self.

5) Design from Intention, Then Let Goals Follow

Why it matters now: Most people pick goals first and reverse-engineer their identity to match. That’s how they end up succeeding at lives that don’t fit.

Mental model:

Flip the order.

1. Intention: “I intend to be someone who [e.g., deeply learns, creates, serves, builds, explores].”

2. Alignment: “What daily behavior would make that true in a small but real way?”

3. Only then: “What goals naturally emerge from repeatedly living that way?”

   
   

For example:

• Intention: “I intend to be someone who treats learning as a craft.”

• Alignment: Study 45 focused minutes per day with full attention.

• Goals that emerge: publish a thesis, build a course, switch careers, etc.

  
  

Benefit:

Goals become downstream of who you’re becoming.

If a goal stops matching your intention, you don’t collapse — you simply redesign the goal.

You are no longer asking, “How do I force myself to chase this?” You’re asking, “Does this still belong to the story I want to live?”

Who You Must Become

You don’t need a perfect 2026 roadmap.

You don’t need a ten-year vision that impresses a panel. You don’t need to pretend you know more than you do.

What you need is to become the kind of person who can:

• tell the truth about what you no longer want,

• design experiments instead of worshipping fantasies,

• and realign your life as your insight expands.

  
  

The world is shifting from rigid scripts to self-authored lives.

The old archetype was the Goal-Chaser: clear target, narrow tunnel, impressive resume, quiet misalignment.

The emerging archetype is the Intention-Builder: grounded in evolving values, willing to adjust, more loyal to truth than to past promises.

You are not being asked to know exactly where you’re going.

You are being asked to take responsibility for how you move: honestly, experimentally, awake to feedback, willing to rewrite the plan without abandoning yourself.

If you accept that you are insight-limited, rigid goals will always be illusions. But alignment doesn’t have to be.

The doorway in front of you is simple: Stop trying to predict the final shape of your life. Start becoming the kind of human who can keep reshaping it with courage, clarity, and intention — no matter what you discover next.